Skip to content
NEW PACKAGES - CONTENT AND EMAIL MARKETING >>>>READ MORE
Promotional Posts Rarely Work in Facebook Groups

Promotional Posts Rarely Work in Facebook Groups

Spend a few minutes in almost any local Facebook group, and you’ll notice three types of posts.

The first is someone asking about a community issue, like “anyone else’s red bin not collected today?” or “beware of the giant pothole on Smith Street”.

The second is a local business introducing themselves, promoting a special offer or reminding everyone what they do. 

The third is someone asking a question or recommendation such as, “Can anyone recommend a good accountant?” or “Who’s the best pressure washing business in the area?”.

Some posts attract dozens of comments, others receive a like or two and disappear down the feed. After watching local Facebook groups for years, I don’t think that’s a coincidence. It says a lot about how people use these communities, and it’s very different to how many businesses try to market themselves.

People Join Communities, Not for Advertisements 

People aren’t opening a local Facebook group hoping to see businesses advertising their services. The groups that are full of ads, get very little community engagement. People are looking for local knowledge, advice and recommendations from people who have already used a local business.

That’s why recommendation posts generate so much activity, they help people make buying decisions with confidence.

Image – see all of the recommendations on these posts.

The Businesses People Remember

When you spend enough time in these groups, you notice the same businesses recommended again and again. These businesses aren’t posting promotional graphics every week, but they are known in the community. 

A happy customer will recommend a local business that has done great work for them. This often results in further comments, like “Yes, I’ve used them too, they were great”. Businesses also become known by contributing to conversations over time, answering questions and sharing their knowledge. Either way, people are remembering them.

The Opportunity Most Businesses Miss

Many businesses wait for the next advertising day before becoming active in a Facebook group. I’ve even seen people share spreadsheets and lists showing the advertising days for dozens of local groups. If that’s the only way you use Facebook groups for your business, you’re missing where most of the buying conversations actually happen. 

Recommendation posts are happening every day. Those conversations are where people are actively looking for a service. They’re asking who to trust, who others would use again and who has a good reputation.

Being part of those conversations is often far more valuable than publishing another promotional post that disappears within a day or two.

People Search Before They Ask

A recommendation post doesn’t end when the original question has been answered. Not everyone creates a new post when they need a service, many people search the group first. 

They’ll search for accountant, bookkeeper, pressure washing or web designer to see who has already been recommended, they often don’t need to ask the question again. Those older conversations continue working long after they’ve disappeared from the news feed, months or even years later.

Image – see the dates in these searches.

If your business appears across several of those conversations, people begin seeing your name repeatedly, and you become known for your product or service. That familiarity grows over time, even if they don’t contact you the first time they come across it.

Facebook Groups Can Reach Beyond Facebook

The conversation doesn’t just stay inside the Facebook group; it can have a bigger advantage. Some public Facebook discussions are indexed by Google, meaning someone searching online may come across recommendation posts from a Facebook group without ever opening Facebook first. There are no guarantees every conversation will appear in search results, but it’s another reason those helpful discussions often have a much longer life than businesses realise.

Image – public groups can be indexed by Google

How We Approach Facebook Groups

At Creative Desk, Facebook groups are one part of our Social Media Management service, but probably not in the way you’d expect.

Rather than filling groups with promotional posts, we keep an eye on local communities where our clients’ ideal customers are already asking questions and looking for recommendations. When there’s a genuine opportunity, we’ll let our clients know so they can join the conversation, or help them respond in a way that’s helpful and relevant.

It’s one of the ways we help businesses become more visible in the communities they want to work in, alongside managing their social media accounts and creating content that keeps them front of mind.

Final Thoughts

The next time you’re scrolling through a local Facebook group, pay attention to the recommendation posts. Which businesses appear over and over again? If your business isn’t one of them yet, that’s probably a better place to focus than creating another promotional post. That’s where Facebook groups often deliver their greatest value. 

Michelle Tolhurst is the Founder and Director of Creative Desk, an Australian marketing agency supporting service-based businesses across Australia. With over 25 years of marketing experience and more than a decade leading her own agency, she has supported over 150 businesses. Michelle and her team help time-poor business owners move from marketing overwhelm to clarity, confidence and consistency.

Back To Top